
Google now gives website owners a set of switches for AI — and a lot of business owners are about to flip the wrong one.
In the last few weeks, the trade press has been full of headlines about “opting out of AI”. Google announced on 30 October that it plans to support a single shared rule for opting out of AI training, and Microsoft and OpenAI said they will honour it too. At the same time, a Search Console setting that removes your site from Google’s AI answers has been live for every website worldwide since 31 August.
They sound like the same thing. They are not. One switch takes you out of the AI answers your customers read. Another stops your content being used to train future AI models. A third does something else entirely. Flip the wrong one and you can quietly disappear from the exact place your customers are looking — while the thing you were worried about keeps happening anyway.
Here is what each control actually does, and what a Surrey small business should do about it.
The three things people mix up
Before the switches, get the three ideas straight:
- AI answers — the AI-written summaries at the top of Google results (AI Overviews) and the chat-style answers in AI Mode. This is where your customers increasingly read first.
- AI training — using your website content to teach future AI models. This is invisible to your customers and mostly invisible to you.
- Regular Search ranking — where your pages appear in the normal list of results. None of the AI switches below is a ranking switch, and Google says so plainly.
| Control | Where you set it | What it does | What it does not do |
|---|---|---|---|
| Search generative AI control — Exclude | Search Console: Settings, then Search generative AI | Removes your links and content from AI Overviews, AI Mode and AI features in Discover | Does not affect your regular Search ranking. Does not affect AI training. |
| Google-Extended blocked | robots.txt | Limits use of your content to train future Gemini models, and to ground answers in Gemini Apps and Vertex AI | Does not affect your inclusion in Google Search, AI Overviews or AI Mode. |
| Shared training token __usage_ai-training (planned) | robots.txt, from 2027 | Opts you out of AI training across the AI companies that adopt it | Google has not said it changes anything in Search. |
| nosnippet | Robots meta tag, per page | Stops text snippets in all Google results, including AI Overviews and AI Mode | Also strips snippets from your regular results. |
| noindex | Robots meta tag, per page | Removes the page from Google Search completely | Nothing — the page is gone from Search. |
The Search Console switch: out of AI answers, out of the conversation
The Search generative AI control is a three-option setting inside Search Console, Google’s free tool for website owners. Google announced it on 3 June 2026, tested it with a subset of website owners in the UK, and rolled it out to all websites worldwide — Canadian sites included — on 31 August 2026.
The three options are:
- Include (the default): your content can appear in AI Overviews, AI Mode and AI features in Discover, and you can get traffic from them.
- Exclude: your links and content stop appearing. Google’s help page is blunt about the cost: “You won’t receive any traffic or impressions from these features.”
- Inherit: one part of your site follows the setting of the property above it.
Google says a change “generally takes a few days” to take effect, and that the control “isn’t used as a ranking or inclusion signal affecting other parts of Search” — your regular rankings do not move. But it also says, in the same help page, “This control doesn’t affect AI training.” Your content may still be used to train models and “to power Google Search as a whole”, for example to understand the language of searches.
So if your worry is “Google is training on my content”, this switch does not fix it. And if your worry is “I don’t want to be in AI answers”, this is the switch — but read the next section before you touch it.
The robots.txt switches: training, not answers
Google-Extended is the older control. It is a line in your robots.txt file — the small text file on your website that tells crawlers what they may use. Blocking Google-Extended limits use of your content to train future Gemini models, and also limits its use for grounding answers in the Gemini app and Vertex AI. Google says it “does not impact a site’s inclusion in Google Search” — and that includes AI Overviews and AI Mode. Blocking it does not take you out of the AI answers.
The new development is the shared training token. On 30 October 2026, Google’s John Mueller wrote on the Search Central blog that Google plans “to support a shared AI training control in robots.txt”, based on work from the IETF’s AI Preferences working group. The rule looks like this:
User-Agent: __usage_ai-training Disallow: /
One line, and in theory every AI company that adopts it honours it. Google says it intends to support it in early 2027. Microsoft will start honouring the new training and grounding preferences from 1 February 2027, and after 1 March 2027 its old signals — NoArchive and NoCache used as AI preferences — stop counting. OpenAI has said it will honour the shared line too, in the coming months.
Two catches to know now. First, the shared rule is not live with Google yet — adding it today does nothing at Google until early 2027, so for anything you want honoured now, you still need the per-company tokens such as Google-Extended and GPTBot. Second, if you opt out with the shared token and do not mention Google-Extended separately, Google plans to treat that as if you had disallowed Google-Extended — which also blocks your content being used to ground answers in the Gemini app. That is a trade-off, not a free win: blocking training can also cost you citations in Gemini.
The two traps: nosnippet and noindex
Two older tools get suggested for this job, and both are heavier than they look:
- nosnippet stops text snippets in all Google results, including AI Overviews and AI Mode — but it also strips the snippet from your regular results, so your listing shows up as a bare link. The page stays indexed; it just looks worse everywhere.
- noindex removes the page from Google Search completely. That is not opting out of AI. That is opting out of Google.
Neither is the right tool for “I want to stay in Search but out of AI answers”. The Search Console control is.
So should a Surrey business opt out?
For most Surrey small businesses, the honest answer is no — and the reason is what happens after you opt out. The AI answer does not go away. It still appears at the top of the results; it just appears without your link in it. You have not taken your customer back. You have taken yourself out of the answer they read first.
That matters more every month. Analytics firm Sistrix, tracking more than 100 million search terms in Germany, found Google has shown an AI Overview for more than half of search terms since 2 November 2026, reaching 57.9% on 6 November. That is one provider, one market, and a directional read — not a promise about Surrey searches — but the direction is clear, and it matches what we have been writing about here: AI answers are where the customer reads first, and reviews decide which businesses the AI recommends. Opting out of the answers while your competitors stay in is a strange way to compete.
There are real cases for opting out, and they are narrower than the headlines suggest:
- You sell or license the content itself. If your website’s content is the product — paid guides, licensed data, original research — and the AI answer gives it away for free, excluding it from AI answers is a legitimate business decision.
- The AI answer fully replaces the visit, and you gain nothing from it. If people get everything they need from the summary and never click, and your business model depends on the visit, opting out is worth weighing — but weigh it honestly, because the summary will still exist without you.
- Privacy-sensitive content. If a page should not be quoted in an AI answer for reasons of privacy or client confidentiality, excluding it is the right call — though noindex may be more appropriate if it should not be in Search at all.
For everyone else — a trades business, a clinic, a restaurant, a professional service — the default is to stay in, and to do the work that makes staying in pay: clear pages that answer real questions, a current Google Business Profile, and a review profile that makes the AI recommend you rather than your competitor.
A 3-check this week
This takes about fifteen minutes, and it is worth doing before the year ends — Google keeps changing AI Mode (it added private temporary threads on 17 November), so settings are worth confirming after each big change:
- Check your Search Console setting. In Search Console, open Settings, then Search generative AI. Confirm it says Include — unless someone chose Exclude on purpose. If you do not have Search Console access, ask whoever manages your website. (If Digital Allo manages your site, ask us — we will check it as part of your SEO work.)
- Read your robots.txt file. Visit yoursite.ca/robots.txt and look for lines naming Google-Extended. Make sure they match what you want. If you want to limit Gemini training now, block Google-Extended — it does not touch your Search visibility.
- Set a reminder for early 2027. That is when Google plans to support the shared __usage_ai-training rule. When it lands, review it once, decide on training as a separate question from AI answers, and leave the Search Console setting alone unless you have a reason to change it.
The bottom line
Google has given you three different switches, and they do three different things. The Search Console control takes you out of AI answers. Google-Extended limits Gemini training. The shared robots.txt rule, coming in 2027, will do training opt-outs across companies at once. Confusing them is easy, and the cost of the confusion falls on the business that disappears from the answer its customers read first.
For most Surrey businesses, the right setting is the one you already have: Include. Check it, check your robots.txt, and put the 2027 date in your calendar. Then get back to the work that actually wins the AI answer — clear pages, real reviews, and a business worth recommending.
FAQ
How do I remove my website from AI Overviews and AI Mode? Use the Search generative AI control in Google Search Console: Settings, then Search generative AI, and choose Exclude. Google says the change generally takes a few days, and it does not affect your regular Search rankings — but you will receive no traffic or impressions from AI Overviews, AI Mode or AI features in Discover.
Does opting out of AI Overviews stop Google training AI on my content? No. Google’s own help page says the Search generative AI control “doesn’t affect AI training.” To limit training, use robots.txt rules such as Google-Extended, and from 2027 the shared __usage_ai-training token.
Does blocking Google-Extended remove me from AI Overviews? No. Google says Google-Extended “does not impact a site’s inclusion in Google Search”, and that includes AI Overviews and AI Mode. It limits training of future Gemini models and grounding in Gemini Apps.
What is the shared __usage_ai-training rule? It is a single robots.txt rule that opts your site out of AI training across the AI companies that adopt it. Google announced on 30 October 2026 that it plans to support it in early 2027; Microsoft starts honouring it from 1 February 2027 and OpenAI has said it will honour it too. It is not live with Google yet.
Should a Surrey small business opt out of Google’s AI answers? Usually not. The AI answer still appears without your link, so you lose the traffic without winning the customer back. The main exceptions are businesses that sell or license their content, and pages with privacy-sensitive material. For most local businesses, staying in — with clear pages and strong reviews — is the better move.
Will opting out hurt my Google rankings? Google says the Search generative AI control “isn’t used as a ranking or inclusion signal affecting other parts of Search”, so your regular rankings should not change. You do lose all traffic and impressions from AI Overviews, AI Mode and AI features in Discover.



