
The button disappeared — for some people
On 13 November 2026, SEO consultant Glenn Gabe posted screenshots of a Google results page that looked wrong. The AI Mode tab — the one that has sat in the tab bar since Google launched AI Mode in May 2025 — was gone. And the “Ask anything” follow-up box that normally sits under an AI Overview, inviting you to continue the conversation in AI Mode, was gone too. Gabe asked whether Google was “really testing removing AI Mode”.
Search Engine Roundtable reported it the same afternoon. Its editor, Barry Schwartz, could not reproduce the missing tab on his own searches — which points to a test on a small group of users, not a rollout. Google has made no statement about it, and none of the reports describe AI Overviews themselves being removed.
This was not the first sighting. On 30 October, a single user reported the AI Mode button missing from the search bar. On 3 November, Search Engine Roundtable reported that another user had lost the AI Mode button on the Google homepage. An independent check by SaaS Link Building on 14 November — 51 logged-out results pages across 31 queries, on US and UK desktop and US mobile — found no sign of the test on desktop at all, and the AI Mode tab missing on only 2 of 14 mobile pages. Both of those queries showed the tab again when fetched a second time, minutes later. So the test is small, flaky, and so far mostly mobile.
In other words: Google is checking what happens when it stops pointing people toward AI Mode. It has not announced that AI Mode is going away. But it is measuring the door, and that tells you something about the room behind it.
The money came first
There is a reason Google would test this now, and it is the same reason the test is worth your attention: the ads inside AI answers are not earning what traditional search ads earn.
On Alphabet’s third-quarter earnings call in late October, chief business officer Philipp Schindler said AI Mode queries currently earn less than traditional search ads. Google’s own executives have now said it out loud: the AI surface monetises at a lower rate per query.
The ChatGPT side of the same story arrived a few weeks earlier, in a working paper from researchers at the Vienna University of Economics and Business (WU Vienna) and the Frankfurt School of Finance & Management. Kaiser and Schulze tracked 1,898 online shops through ChatGPT’s country-by-country ad rollout — nearly 10 billion visitor sessions over 60 weeks, from June 2025 to August 2026, using Google Analytics e-commerce data supplied by Grips Intelligence. For US traffic, a paid ChatGPT visit generated $0.89 in revenue, against $2.45 for a paid Google Search visit. ChatGPT ad visitors bought at 0.37%, against 1.17% for Google Search. Measured at paid search’s rate of return, the authors calculate that a ChatGPT click is worth about $0.26 to an advertiser. The largest publicly known account in their data paid $1.72 per click — more than six times that. And 82% of the 102 advertisers in the study recorded no purchases at all from their ChatGPT ads.
Read those numbers with the caveats the authors themselves flag, because they matter: the paper is a working paper, version 1, still under peer review — early evidence, not a settled verdict. The data window closed on 22 August 2026, before ads reached the EU and before most of the product changes OpenAI has made since. The tracking captures only the last click, so a ChatGPT click that led to a purchase a week later through Google would count for Google. And one advertiser made up most of the paid ChatGPT revenue in the data, which is why the $0.26 estimate carries a wide range ($0.05 to $0.57). Even with all of that, the direction is hard to ignore: at today’s prices, AI-chat ads are a long way from paying like search ads.
There is one more finding in the paper worth knowing. The arrival of ChatGPT ads coincided with an estimated 6 to 8% drop in the free, organic referrals ChatGPT sends to shops. In other words, the ads did not just underperform — they may have eaten some of the free traffic that used to come from being mentioned in ChatGPT’s answers.
The counter-signal: Google is still building AI Mode, too
Before anyone declares AI Mode finished, note what happened on the very same day as Gabe’s screenshots. At 17:53 UTC on 13 November, Robby Stein, Google’s VP of Product for Search, announced that AI Mode can now connect to Adobe, Calm and Peloton — apps inside the AI answer, so you can do things there rather than just read about them. Google is still investing in AI Mode on the same day it tests hiding the door to it.
That contradiction is the point. Google is running two experiments at once: making AI Mode more capable, and checking how many people reach it when it stops pointing them there. The company has not explained the tests, and any reason offered for them is speculation — including the revenue one. What is confirmed is only this: a small, flaky test, no announcement, and an earnings call where Google said AI ads earn less.
Google is also still rearranging the AI surfaces themselves. Search Engine Roundtable published screenshots on 2 November showing AI Overviews for brand searches moving into the right-hand column, where the knowledge panel used to live, instead of the big block at the top. Google has not announced that either. The buttons keep moving. The surfaces keep shifting. That is the environment your marketing has to survive in — and it is exactly why you should not build your plan on any single button.
What this means for a Surrey business
First, don’t panic — and don’t celebrate. AI Mode is not being removed. The test covers a small group, Schwartz could not reproduce it, and the SaaS Link Building pull caught it twice on mobile and never on desktop. AI Overviews are not part of the test at all. If someone tells you “SEO is dead” because of this, they are selling you something.
Second, don’t move your Black Friday budget into AI ads yet. Black Friday is Friday 27 November — nine days away. The evidence says AI-chat ads do not convert like search ads at current prices, and Google’s own chief business officer says AI Mode ads earn less. That is not the week to test a new, expensive placement with real money. Keep the budget where it converts — Google Search and Shopping — and use the Invalid Traffic Overview card to check what you are actually paying for (we covered that card in our earlier post).
Third, keep being findable in AI answers anyway. The “Ask anything” box is how a reader moves from an AI Overview into an AI Mode conversation. If it disappears for some users, fewer people take that second step — but the AI Overview itself, and the links and citations inside it, are still there, and they are still the first thing many searchers see. Reviews still decide which businesses AI recommends, and your Google reviews can now appear inside your own ads. None of that changed on 13 November.
Fourth, Google’s own advice hasn’t changed. Its guidance still says there are no extra requirements to appear in AI Overviews or AI Mode: your page needs to be indexed and eligible to show a snippet — the same standard as a normal search result. No special file, no special schema, no separate submission. And Google has said plainly that it doesn’t read llms.txt files. If someone is selling you a special AI-visibility file this week, you don’t need it.
The 5-step check to run before Black Friday
- Step 1 — Keep Black Friday spend in Google Search and Shopping. Don’t test ChatGPT ads or AI Mode ads with real money this week. The study says a ChatGPT click is worth about $0.26 at search’s rate of return; the biggest known account paid $1.72. Test later, with a small, capped budget, when you can measure it properly — not in the nine days before your biggest sales week.
- Step 2 — Check the Invalid Traffic Overview card. Open Google Ads, go to Campaigns, then Overview, and look at the new card: estimated savings before billing, and credited cost after the billing period. Know what you actually paid for before you raise budgets for Black Friday. (Full walk-through in our earlier post.)
- Step 3 — Make sure your Google Business Profile is complete and your reviews are current. Reviews decide which businesses AI recommends, and they now feed your ad copy too. A profile with an old phone number, wrong hours or six reviews against a competitor’s seventy is a problem on every surface — classic search, AI Overviews and AI Mode alike.
- Step 4 — Check your own AI visibility in Search Console. Under Performance, then Search results, then Generative AI, you can see how often your pages appear in AI Overviews and AI Mode. Annotate two dates in your dashboard before you read it: 10 November, when the core update started, and 12 November, when Gemini 4 Hydrogen became the default model in AI Mode. Citation data for November now spans a model change, so don’t compare it to October without that note. (And remember the Search Console Generative AI report had a data-logging bug on 9–11 November — that was logging only, not rankings.)
- Step 5 — Don’t rebuild your strategy around one button. Google moved the AI Mode button off its homepage, tested removing the tab, and added apps to AI Mode — all in the same fortnight. Build on the things that don’t move: clear service pages, real reviews, a fast site, correct business information, and content that answers the questions your customers actually ask. Those work on every surface Google shows, whichever button it hides next.
The bottom line
Google is testing what happens when it stops pointing people at AI Mode, and the first independent study of AI-chat ads says the clicks are worth far less than advertisers are paying. Neither fact kills AI search — and neither fact kills SEO. What they do say is that the AI surfaces are still being priced, tested and rearranged, and the classic search result is still the surface that pays.
For a Surrey business nine days from Black Friday, the move is boring and correct: keep the money where it converts, keep your profile and reviews in shape, check your own Search Console data, and watch 3 December — Similarweb’s November roundup flags that as the date for Google’s first official click data. That is the number to judge, not a screenshot of a missing tab.
Want Digital Allo to check your ad spend and AI visibility before Black Friday? We run Google Ads management and PPC services in Surrey, including the Invalid Traffic card check, and our SEO services and AI search visibility work covers the citations and reviews that get you mentioned in AI answers. Start with a free AI Opportunity Assessment, or contact us — (604) 401-0699.
FAQ
Is Google removing AI Mode? No. Google is testing removing the AI Mode tab from the search tab bar and the “Ask anything” box from AI Overviews for a small group of users — first spotted 13 November 2026. Search Engine Roundtable’s editor could not reproduce it, and Google has made no announcement. AI Overviews themselves are not part of the test.
Do AI Mode ads earn less than traditional search ads? Yes, according to Google itself. On Alphabet’s third-quarter earnings call in late October 2026, chief business officer Philipp Schindler said AI Mode queries currently earn less than traditional search ads. Google has not published a figure for how much less.
Are ChatGPT ads worth the money? The first independent study says not at current prices. Researchers at WU Vienna and the Frankfurt School tracked 1,898 online shops and found a paid ChatGPT visit generated $0.89 in revenue in the US, against $2.45 for a paid Google Search visit, and converted at 0.37% against 1.17%. They calculate a ChatGPT click is worth about $0.26 at paid search’s rate of return; the largest publicly known account paid $1.72 per click. The paper is a working paper under peer review, so treat it as early evidence.
Should my business move its ad budget into AI Mode or ChatGPT ads? Not yet, and not before Black Friday. The evidence says AI-chat ads convert worse than search ads at current prices. Keep the budget in Google Search and Shopping where it converts, test AI placements later with a small capped budget, and check the Invalid Traffic Overview card in Google Ads to see what you are actually paying for.
Does the AI Mode test change how I get into AI Overviews? No. Google’s guidance hasn’t changed: to appear in AI Overviews or AI Mode, your page needs to be indexed and eligible to show a snippet — the same standard as a normal search result. No special file or schema is required, and Google says it doesn’t read llms.txt files.



